“Coffee’s not coffee! Coffee is sex!”

How I Learned to read in-between the lines …

We’ve all had those moments—we think we’re being respectful, responsible, or just plain polite… only to realize later we completely missed the point. Not the words. The moment. The invitation. The hint.

And no one captures that confusion better than George Costanza.

There’s a classic Seinfeld episode where George returns from a date, puzzled. The woman had invited him up for coffee. George, ever the literal guy, declines: “I can’t drink coffee this late.” Later, it hits him: “Coffee’s not coffee! Coffee is sex!”

It’s hilarious—because it’s painfully true. At least, it was for me.

As someone who tries to be thoughtful but has the radar of a toaster when it comes to subtle cues, I’ve missed more signals than I care to admit. For all my efforts to be tuned in, I seem to be operating on airplane mode when it comes to nonverbal communication.

A few years ago, I had a great first date. Casual drinks, good conversation, real spark. As we reached her condo, she smiled and said, “Hey, want to come up and check out this Netflix doc I was telling you about? It’s only 40 minutes.”

I smiled back and said, “Ah, I would—but if I start something now, I won’t get to bed at a decent hour. I’ve got an early start.”
She nodded and said, “Sure… next time then.”

I walked away thinking I’d nailed the night: great vibes, respectful exit, second date on deck.

The next day, I told a friend. He squinted: “Wait—you thought she wanted to watch a documentary? At midnight? After drinks?”
Cue the gut-punch.

The "Netflix" wasn’t about documentaries—it was about connection. A moment to see where things could go. But I was too focused on being polite to realize what was actually being offered.

Sadly, not the only time I missed the mark.

Another time, a woman I’d been texting invited me to hang out: “Nothing fancy, maybe some takeout and chill.” I showed up with food and suggested we keep the lights bright so we could “see the menu better.” We ate, chatted, and I did the dishes before heading out early—thinking I was being a gentleman.

She never texted again.

Looking back, I wasn’t just blind—I was brilliantly blind. But I wasn’t clueless. The truth is, I was hiding behind politeness to avoid vulnerability. I felt the vibe, but instead of checking in, I played it safe. I didn’t want to misread her or make it awkward.

In hindsight, I wasn’t protecting her—I was protecting me. From rejection, from looking foolish. But in playing it cool, I missed the chance to be real.

Here’s what I’ve learned:

1. Context matters more than words.
Tone, timing, body language—all speak louder than the sentence itself. “Come up for coffee” at midnight rarely means coffee.

2. Clarifying can be respectful.
Asking, “Is this your way of saying the night doesn’t have to end yet?” isn’t pushy—it’s honest, playful, and clear.

3. Politeness shouldn’t be a shield.
I used to think being polite made me mature. But often, that “safe” distance is just fear dressed up. Presence takes more courage than passivity.

4. Missed it? Learn and move on.
We all misread sometimes. The key is learning to stay open and aware next time.

And let’s be clear—it’s not just men who miss signals.

A female friend once told me about a cabin weekend trip her friend group had planned. One of the quieter guys in the group, someone she always liked, casually said, “Hey, if you’re not doing anything before we leave Friday, I’m grabbing lunch—wanna come?”

She declined, saying she had errands. Later that day, she admitted, “I kind of wish I’d gone. I think he was trying to hang out one-on-one.”

I asked, “Did you want to?”
She sighed. “Yeah. But I didn’t want to make it weird.”

Missed signals aren’t just romantic. They show up in friendships, work, and everyday connection. Whether it’s coffee, lunch, or a casual “hang,” small gestures can carry big meaning. Too often, we talk ourselves out of leaning in.

So now, when someone says coffee, chill, or grab lunch real quick, I don’t overthink it—but I don’t ignore it either. I try to stay present, read the room, and avoid being the guy who realizes too late, mid-shower: “Oh no… that wasn’t about coffee.”

Question for You:
Ever had one of those “Ohhh… that’s what they meant” moments? What would you do differently if you got a second chance?

Got a moment you realized way too late? Share it—I promise, you’re in good company.

Don’t hesitate to pass this on to anyone who may find it valuable.

Please join us on our Facebook group to share your thoughts and join the Blessed Ways of Life community: Blessed Ways of life | Facebook

Relatable article: Navigating Modern Dating — Blessed Ways of Life

Youtube Video: The Power of Forgiveness

Youtube Short: Deliverance Comes in Gods Timing, Not Ours 

Personal Reflection: