What Matters More?
Emotions or Expectations?
Working on a betterment, see our membership articles for next steps and best tools: Membership — Blessed Ways of Life or contact us at info@blessedwaysoflife.com for more information.
I’m a Non-Smoker Who Dated a Smoker — Here’s What I Learned
I used to date someone who smoked. As a lifelong non-smoker, I always imagined that would be a hard dealbreaker — something that crossed a line I wasn’t willing to blur. But when I met this person, everything else about them felt incredibly aligned. They were kind, thoughtful, emotionally open, and made me feel seen in a way I hadn’t experienced in a long time.
So, I made a choice. I decided not to let that one detail — their smoking — be the reason I walked away from something that felt emotionally rich and full of potential. And that decision brought up deeper questions: What really matters in love? Are emotions more important than the checklist we carry into relationships?
Most of us have a mental list when it comes to dating — even if we don’t admit it. We want someone who doesn’t smoke, is financially stable, shares our faith or values, communicates well, maybe even likes the same music or has the same sense of humor. These “checkmarks” help us feel like we’re building a smart, safe future.
But what happens when someone comes along who doesn’t check every box — but feels emotionally right in all the ways that count?
Emotions vs. Expectations
Falling in love isn’t a checklist activity. It’s messy, spontaneous, and often bypasses logic. You connect with someone on a deep level, then suddenly realize — they do something you don’t like. In my case, it was the smoking. For others, it might be spending habits, dietary choices, or social expectations.
These aren’t moral failings — just differences. But they force you to reckon with the tension between how someone makes you feel and how well they match your imagined criteria.
The Illusion of the Perfect Fit
We’re taught that true compatibility means alignment in habits and values — and that the “right person” will tick every box. But that’s rarely how love works. Often, the people who challenge our checklist the most are the ones who teach us the most about ourselves.
Differences don’t always mean incompatibility. In fact, some can create balance. The key is knowing the difference between a negotiable habit and a non-negotiable value.
Habits vs. Core Values
In my situation, smoking was a personal preference — something I didn’t love, but not a reflection of my partner’s character. They were respectful and willing to compromise — not smoking around me or in closed spaces. That made a big difference.
It’s important to ask: Is this trait hurting the relationship or just making me uncomfortable? Is this a values clash or a lifestyle difference?
Someone who spends freely might not be financially irresponsible — they might just have a different philosophy. Someone who smokes might not be careless — they may use it for stress or comfort. The difference lies in how they respond to your concerns and whether they’re open to understanding your side.
Emotions Are Valid — So Are Boundaries
Loving someone doesn’t mean ignoring your discomfort. Emotions are real, but so are your needs. Boundaries matter. They aren’t about changing the other person — they’re about protecting your own well-being.
Talk openly. “I” statements help: “I feel overwhelmed by cigarette smoke and worry about the long-term effects.” Respect, not judgment, makes space for understanding and compromise.
If your partner listens, adjusts, and cares about your concerns, that’s a sign of emotional maturity. If they dismiss or belittle them — that’s a red flag.
From Checklists to Check-Ins
Instead of constantly measuring your partner against a list, try checking in with yourself and each other. Ask:
Am I being heard?
Are we growing together, even through our differences?
Do I feel safe, respected, and emotionally fulfilled?
Real love isn’t about finding a perfect match. It’s about creating one — through patience, communication, and mutual care.
Making the Difference a Non-Issue
Here’s how you can keep differences — like smoking, spending habits, or social quirks — from becoming dealbreakers:
Communicate Early and Gently – Use openness, not criticism.
Understand the Why – Learn what drives the habit. Understanding leads to empathy.
Set Healthy Boundaries – Define what works for both of you.
Compromise, Don’t Control – Seek middle ground, not domination.
Prioritize Core Values Over Preferences – Focus on the things that truly affect emotional connection and long-term vision.
Love Beyond the Checklist
At the end of the day, love is more than shared interests and aligned habits. It’s about choosing someone — over and over — even when they miss a few boxes. It’s about being open to the idea that your version of the “ideal partner” might not look exactly how you imagined, but they might feel exactly right.
So yes, I’m a non-smoker that dated a smoker. And while it challenged my preferences, it also challenged me to grow — to lead with love, to speak with care, and to hold space for the beautiful, complicated ways that two people can choose each other despite the odds.
Because falling in love isn’t about finding a clone of yourself. It’s about finding someone worth building bridges for.
Please don’t hesitate to pass this on to anyone who may find it valuable.
Inspired story: Money & Marriage: What Your Financial Setup Says About Your Relationship — Blessed Ways of Life
Please join us on our Facebook group to share your thoughts and join the Blessed Ways of Life community: Blessed Ways of life | Facebook
Youtube Video: Reclaim Your Peace A Blessed Ways of Life Mentorship Experience #personalgrowth #mentalhealth
Short Video: Why Kids Lie and What They're Really Trying to Tell You
Personal Reflection:
